I am a subscriber to some literary journals published in India. Of course, I am a reader of some of the world’s leading literary review journals, notably, the 100 and odd year old Times Literary Supplement, TLS of great fame. TLS has been a reading habit with me, now, I don’t know for how many years. Perhaps, as long as I have been in Oxford and it is a long time indeed.

This attachment to TLS has grown with me in time and perhaps my reading habits and my reading tastes and my literary appreciation must have been impact by the TLS style of writing and the TLS way of looking at things, mostly literary.

TLS review of the classics, philosophy, poetry and of course much of history and biographies have been my staple reading and I have greatly benefited by reading these pages.TLS also helps me to keep in touch with the latest publications, in particular the Oxford philosophy titles, my special interest.

But then there are of course the equally the British appetite for book reviews, an all their journals and newspapers. The Guardian reviews lately have not been up to my tastes, they seem to be shallow and cater to the tastes of the current average British newspaper reader. I like the Spectator book reviews and even get these pages often xeroxed so that I can read them at leisure. The Newstatesman was my youthful pursuit, I knew Kingsley Martin and I also used to write letters to it as an Oxford undergraduate, I became a Fabian Socialist and I invited once Mr.Martin to speak to Oxford Indian and Pakistani joint Majlis meeting and so I became familiar with all the Socialists of yore, Julian Stratchy, Victor Gollanz and other India hands from Pethick Lawrence to others. Now, as for the Newstatesman reviews, yes, I like to glance at them. That is all. There are others in the Nature and even in The Economist and other British journals. I read them, yes, now and then. That is all. As for sustained interest I still confine myself to TLS.

After all I tell myself that life is short and you have to pick and choose, don’t you?

Now, as for keeping up myself with updated what is happening inside India I just pay my subscriptions to some journals I pick once or twice when I visit  some five star hotel bookstalls.

That is how I got to get the addresses of a few journals.

One is The Book Review published by a trust. The other is the Biblio: A review of books. As for others and other fields, for literature I subscribe now to the Sahitya Akademy’s Indian Literature.

I was one of the early subscribers of this journal. In fact, I still possess the first copy of the first edition of the Indian Literature when the great Krishna Kripalani (an old Santiniketan hand, was the Secretary. I also knew Prabakar Machwe, a dear friend who introduced me to the world of other language literary names.

I also subscribe now to the Chennai-based music magazine, Shruti.
Yes. I also subscribe to a variety of small magazines in the languages, more for the patronage they need than for anything else.

There are very active groups of poets, short story writers and even language enthusiasts and the extremists of various categories, Marxists, Tamil nationalists and others, Dalit causes and much else.

As for the English learned journals, the Book Review is okey, it is mostly written in an academic language that is very trying on your nerves!
The current and latest one issue, a review on Amrita Shegil by Laila Tyabji is perhaps the best written review for a long time. I enjoyed Ms.Tyabji’s writing style, so polished and so chaste a language and it shows her maturity of mind and a cultivates sense of urbanity and sophistication. It was an enjoyable half an hour!

One example:”All previous writing on Amrita and her art has tantalized, inspired, raised questions, enthralled, exasperated-while conveying only a pale shadow of her brilliant and many faceted self. These two volumes encompass all dimensions, and are deeply, deeply satisfying. There is sadness, delight and gratitude”.

Vivan Sundaram, the nephew of Amrita and the editor of the volumes, must have got a great satisfaction to get such a favourable review from one who is very competent to say what she says.

The Biblio is another literary review journal from Delhi and this trust is also one with eminent names.

Obviously by looking into the very famous names on the trusts of these journals, I wondered why they retain the names that are no more living!
May be there is some snob values for such names.
It is time to be very smart as well as modest and be natural.
Unfortunately anything that comes out of the New Delhi classes, the middle classes are all pretentious.

There is one, the Oxford Cambridge Society of which two of our family members are also members.

Perhaps, this society consisting of some of the most paranoid minds is a reflection of the very artificial and also very insecure world of the New Delhi’s new and old middle classes!

They put the two British Prime Ministers, one and his deputy and at the same breath put Dr.Manmohan Singh and then bring in Rahul Gandhi (to show off  or to cultivate favours?) as they  would be  Deputy Prime Minister!

So, I find the retaining of names long gone, K.R.Narayanan or K.N.Raj or Sham All (the Biblio) is somehow in bad taste and sounds all the enterprises a very bogus exercise!

Anyway, the Biblio is better organised editorial wise and there are some very well-written literary pieces. I enjoyed reading “Imagining the nation in Hindi and Urdu (perhaps we won’t have such writings anywhere else and we need such reviews to focus more on the Indian side of the issues) and give the Indian personality a new priority vs. the Western inspired writing mostly. Another review that caught my attention in the first place is Jaithirtha Rao on Meghnad Desai’s Rediscovering India.

I had already read the book and I consider the book an original contribution to the understanding of where we stand as a nation. Of course, I had also read the intemperate attack of Mani Shankar Ayer on this book for Deasis, rightly in my opinion, focused on the primacy given to the Nehru-Gandhi dynasty as spelling danger to the polity.

There is a review by Inder Malhotra, the veteran editor of Pranay Gupte’s 597 page book Mother India: A political biography of Indira Gandhi. I had read the book. It is boring. Nothing new we don’t know.

Malhotra too didn’t say anything new by way of new insights or wisdom. Indira Gandhi corrupted not the political system; she almost created the new, current politics without any principles. So, the current rich, criminal and corrupt and dynastic elements totally created a meaningless polity.
We need emphasis on the deterioration of governance, the sheer absence of any rationale for a man like Manmohan Singh to hang on as a shadowy character behind the veil of Sonia Gandhi!

The music journal, Shruti is a serious journal devoted to Carnatic music. The trouble is it is so obsessed with Mylapore centric music!
A great pity.

Music, modern day classical music needs some cosmopolitan outlook, some modernity in covering an all India perspective, if not an international perspective.

Indian Literature, published by Sahitya Akademy, is plainly unreadable! Its English language is so academic and the writing style, especially for the literary magazine must be simple and translucent!

It is time Sahitya Akademy either changes its format or stops the publication once for all! Some relief at least!

Image Source : latimesblogs.latimes.com

Convert the historic site as a tourist destination!

Book Review
Sankagiri Fort and Town history
Published by
Priyadharshini Publications,
Old Eadpady Road,Sankagiri-637 301
Salem District, Tamil Nadu
Pages 228,Rs. 160/

This is a rare  regional history  and archeology book. The author Mr.Karunakaran is  a highly qualified student of history, an M.A. in history and later got himself a diploma in epigraphy and archeology. He was born in an agricultural family in a remote  village (Anchettipattu) which is near the  then district town of Sankagiri in the present Salem district.

I write this for the outsiders, total outsiders to the subject of the book. Sankagiri was formerly called Sankaridurg and the town had the uniquely placed hillock, its natural majestic formation must have stirred the conquerors and there were plenty in this part of South India.

The hill and its fort have a long history. As per this book which is written with great diligence and remarkable hard work, there are so many details about the fort and the history of the fort and the town that grew up around the fort. At one point of time in modern British Indian  history, starting from the days of the Mysore rulers, Hyder Ali and his remarkable son, Tipu Sultan, the Sankagiri fort assumed great strategic importance and even before their times, the fort was an important post in the Vijayanagar kingdom and then the Mysore rulers and after the defeat of Tipu Sultan, on May 4,1799 in Srirangapatanam, near Mysore the British thought the Sankagiri fort is so vital for their control of the territory they stationed a critical number of their troops in this remote town! They stayed in this his tile environment till 1825 or so, say the London based  travel guide, the famous  Blue Guide.

In fact, it was in this guide that I first learnt that the British troops were stationed till that year.

Considering how weak Indians are to care to remember their past, their history is very weak when it comes to documentation. So, it is no wonder that not long after the defeat of Tipu Sultan the Sankagiri fort and the town fell into  disuse so to say and the past great times and  historic moments like the dates and years of the visits and may be stays, short and long of such historic figures like Hyder Ali and Tipu Sultan or other British high officers and even before these times, any great Vijayanagar kings or their generals’ visits.

Nor do we know the later history of the region, say, when the period from the fall of Tipu Sultan to the coming of independence, there was the widespread prevalence of the land management system, namely, the zamindari system in this geography.

From what I learnt from this remarkable book is the fact, a rather very strong point of the book is this, there were some notable zamindars ,well educated and sometimes very selfless individuals of remarkable character and I was so fascinated to follow their individual lives and good works, though there were not enough details to quench my thirst!
The subtitle of the book is or rather the very title of the book is: Kongudesa capital city. But many outside Tamil Nadu, why even within Tamil Nadu might not know that this region had a historic capital. For, in my opinion(I am subject to correction) there was no any clearly established Kongu kingdom as such. Nor were there remarkable historic characters like  Desingu Raja of Senchi fort or other palayakarars like the Veerapandiya Kattabomman or the Marudu Brothers in this part of the state. Kongu Nadu was there and there were   very many historic rulers and their kingdoms in this geography.

The first chapter is fact gives a very detailed account of the ancient history of this region and  it makes  a very engrossing reading. In fact, so many new knowledge we are  provided with and anyone interested in the ancient history of the region would benefit immensely. From the Sanga period of the Tamil literature to the  post-Sanga period history. There were so many kingdoms and dynasties and there is a very reliable chronology of these rulers and their kingdoms. Literary minded readers have much to gain from this book, the prevalence of Jains, Buddhists and their contributions to the evolution of the Tamil language, its script and their literature and their religion and philosophy.

There was a long line of the small  Tamil chieftains, called Adiyamans, till 13th century. Each village in these regions seems to have got some historic connections. From Perur to Namakkal, Gunaseelam to others. Also, so many capitals for these so many small kingdoms.

In the meantime there is a detail about the travels of the famed   adventurer, Malikafur who came to the South in 1311 and  the book gives the travel route of this fellow, he went through Omalur and Namakkal and even Thiruchengodu etc!

Again in 1319 and 1323 there were these Muslim adventurers.
It was during the Vijayanagar rule, this city seems to have become a strategic centre. Their rule lasted in Kongu Nadu, says this books, from 1368 to 1667.

Afterwards, the Mysore kings, then the Hyder Ali and son  kept this town as their strategic centre.

Sankagiri served both as  a strategic military post and also treasury and  the toll gate.

There are many names ,local bigwigs of those days who failed to pay the treasury and served terms in the jail in the fort which acquired much notoriety!

There are many other small news that grips our mind and imagination.
Rare  information

This little book has some very rare pieces of information.

For instance, how many know that it was a small time Brahmin, one Purnaiya, who went on to rise up as  a trutes diwan of Tipu Sultan, after 1799, also went on to become the diwan of the newly installed Mysore kingdom by the British.

Hyder Ali was born in Dindugal, near Madurai, as a poor son of a jatka driver!

He became a dictator in 1761.

During the freedom movement, there were many names, small farmers and landowners, who formed a rebel unit and they met Tipu Sultan in(1799(?) and he sent on Khaju Khan(?)  to help them. And so many such small details that are not covered in any other books I have read. Bhavani, Dharapuram were capitals at some times.

British time history of Sankagiri fort and town is very interesting. New land administration, the creation of Ryatwari system as well as the zamindari system brings in new socio-economic changes and new local landlord families emerge.

There is a list  of the British officers that make interesting reading.
There is a reference to the Daniells, Uncle and nephew, who made India of those times immortals through their famed sketches and drawings. I don’t know this before.

If so, the Daniells sketches of Sankagiri can be the basis for some renewal of Sankagiri as a new site for a historic tourist and heritage centre.

Convert Sankagiri fort and town as a historic and archeological and tourist centre.

I have met Mr.K.Karunakaran, the author of this book in Sankagiri recently and congratulated him for the remarkable service he has done for  writing a new genre of trust guide that is detailed and reliable and remarkably objective and based on verified facts.

He had toiled hard for some ten long years to produce the book.
While reading the book I  was struck by the rich historic heritage the small town holds within itself.

If properly developed, Sankagiri fort and the surrounding countryside can be turned into an international tourist centre.

There could be conducted tours once a while and then regulised.
The tour could be about the British sites, their  old dwellings, their cemetery could draw a steady stream of visitors from the British islands.
There could be home stays in the old zamindar buildings and palaces. This could be a heritage tour cum home stays.

A separate scheme could be drawn up and even funds could be tapped to develop this  home stay tourism.

There could be a separate museum with all the historic articles and other objects ,preserved carefully, period-wise.

There could be a library cum research centre. This centre could be tied to some college or university dept.

More conservation, environment protection  measures can be undertaken as part of the urban planning.

More social and cultural meets and cultural programmes and other events can be thought of.

Citizens of Sankagiri and all lovers of Sankagiri fort and township and the large number of the old families can be brought together once for this very purpose of how to make Sankagiri as a more visited and place of interest and relaxation and trekking and much more.

Image Source : indiaplaces.com

For the Americans and the rest of the world
Education’s one more duty!
To impart optimism to a people!

Just now, we read through a longish book review in one of the international journals. It is about the latest two new books on American history. The 20th century America and to be exact the first 10 years of the 21st century, have given America lots of self-doubts. This is because of the 9/11 terrorist attacks that shattered American self-confidence and the subsequent attack by George Bush of Iraq. The first war in Afghanistan, yes, defeated the Taliban and yet the subsequent events showed that though Iraq war was “won”, the Afghan involvement is proving too costly.

Barak Obama and his style of governance raised hopes for the rest of the world and inside America his regime is viewed with many expectations but at the same time with some self-doubt as well.
Why this is so?

You can give as many explanations depending upon whom you are and what is your own self-interest in this question!

A recent visitor to the Sanfrancisco has come back with this experience. He, a young Indian entrepreneur and a highly educated one and yet he, an Oxford graduate entered into the IT industry and made a success of sorts and what he has got to say about the Americans and Sanfracisoeans in particular?

Read More →

by John McCormick, Palgrave macmillan, 2007

Decline of Britain?

Yes, certainly, it looks like that! I was surprised and saddened  to read this book. Surprised to see that Britain as most Indians know it for all these years, the Britain of the great empire is now shrunken into a small nation of just 6o million people, even there you find a high percentage, as much as  7.9 per cent, on-native Britons, most of them from India, Pakistan, Bangladeshis and from West Indies.

There is now a huge racial issue, the immigration of the Asians and the migration of the EU citizens have changed the very face of the old Britain as I knew of it. In fact, I was also interested to see new books, learned treatises, a new book on the UK, Seeking a role: The UK 1951-1970,the latest in the very established series of the New Oxford History of England  series up to the present.

In fact, this volume also coincides my own time in UK in the late Fifties and the early Sixties, one of the defining period in the changed face of the Britain.

Now more than any other, I was shocked also to read just now the latest statistics, that in the last 51 years of its existence, only now comes the news that for the first  time there is a decline in the GDP of the country by as much as 2.1 per cent!  This surely shows the declining economic fortunes of the country that was once the centre of the world.

This book brings me up to date  with the fast changing economic, political and social scenario. There is a gripping sense of nostalgia everywhere in Britain and the tone of the very book here is very sobering and even apologetic.

The British were a highly disciplined people, their class structure is very strong and sustaining but now one sees the old families are disappearing, the Queen herself looks forlorn. Another piece of latest news is that the Queen’s household expenses are running into deficit and she has to seek the government’s help as otherwise, she is dipping into her savings for her expenses. She no more enjoys the privileges of  exclusive air force or navy at her disposal. She doesn’t travel by her own ship nor does she have her own planes for use. She has to charter a commercial aircraft and that too at short notice and that costs money.

Now, the class system once gave Britain its unique leadership of societies ,in all liberal societies of the world. Now, there is a growing middle class and the middle class rise means the decline in old fashioned class system, where there were huge land-owning classes, the old aristocracy gave Britain its unique party system and democracy. Now, the New Labour is very middle and even we can say lower-middle class and there are too many scandals of too silly nature like the MPs claiming false expenses items from the government treasury.

Britain is also becoming a mobile society, too many people are moving into the Southern England and so the population density is also more in the South while Scotland is sparsely populated.

London continues to dominate national life and London defines still the British culture and lifestyle. London is still the home for tennis, in Wimble, football at Wimbley in north London, BBC, cricket in Lords and also home for the world’s best theatres and, opera and ballet and the best centre for the world media. World’ famous newspapers and magazines are still printed and published only from London.

Thus, the glow of London shines yet and still we find the British life is becoming more dull and pedestrian compared with cities elsewhere. New York and  Paris are more vibrant, French culture and style,  fashion and literature is much admired and so too other countries and their growth prospects. Certainly, India and China are the promising nations, Bangalore is the Silicon Valley. The average standard of living in Bangalore seems higher than what we see in the visiting Britons and other Europeans. At any rate, the way Indians do their IT business, outsourcing and their software skills, the way  the average Bangalore IT entrepreneurs do business gives the impression that Indians feel more comfortable to do business with Americans is very smart and very satisfying. To order a book published in London through eBay seems more comfortable and easy than through any  London stores!

So too the comforts of google, twitter and facebook and what have you.

Britons seem to have fallen back in international standards of doing business. The Brits have also become more embedded in their prejudices and what the Brits write about India is unreliable and this would further reduce their standing in the eyes of the world. Now, the social scene in current Britain certainly gives  some discomfort.

The book itself seems

very hesitant to talk openly about the changing and changed class structure in Britain today. Yes, it is noted here that in 1914, there were upper classes, mainly landed aristocracy and perhaps those who served as high ranking army personnel and also civil servants serving in India, like governor generals and viceroys etc. and peasantry, today it is noted that 60-65 per cent of Britons consider themselves as middle class, some non-manual job holders and the working class, that is those who consider themselves as working class is still a high of 30  per cent, bus drivers and laundry men etc and various unskilled men and women doing harsh jobs.

Class differences and distinctions are very high in Britain, because it is said Britain never experienced revolutions and wars as it was in France and Germany and other countries. But still Britain remains an acutely conscious class country, where you would be discerned subtly and unmistakably as to which class you belong. Thus, landownership, residences in the rural countryside is a sign of great social prestige and distinction in Britain.

The Queen seeking 4 million “par rise” is a shrieking headline in the daily newspapers!

And also the education whether you had been to a public school and Oxford matters a great deal in Britain!

But what galled me  beyond belief is  the persistence of large scale poverty in Britain even now. Some harsh social realities also hit hard on your face.
Briefly, there is  a vast poor, single parent family are poor, there is a wide and widening gap between the rich and the poor. Children born outside the marriage is huge, one-sixth of the population,40 per cent of the children are born outside marriage, divorces are so high, and a decline in social stigma attached to divorcees, the Queen’s family itself is now a big source of family breakdowns!
2.5 million children are living in families that are below poverty line, really a very highly unacceptable proportion for  a country of Britain’s  affluence.

So too a high homeless population, officialy 1,50,000 families and unofficially double the size, says the book.

Even in life expectancy, Britain comes eighth, after Japan, Spain, Australia, Canada, Italy and France.

There are also political developments inside Britain, Wales and Scotland has now separate Asssemblies, the Ireland division is still a simmering issue.
What will be the future of Britain from now onwards?

Britain  still entertains many illusions of grandeyes, it is a grand delusion now!
USA doesn’t care much for the so-called Atlantic  special relationship, Commonwelath is as good as gone for ever, and Britian faces the prospect of adjusting its vision to the hard realities of the contemporary world.
The lessons for outsiders, more so Indians who still seem to be taken in by the hang-ups of the past.

Britain is a middle level Third World type country, with little prospects to compete with the emerging big nations like China and India and even countries like Iran and other Gulf nations.

May be Britain  can win friends and influence the peoples of the world if it concentrates on its inherent strengths.

It is a country of very high quality education, it has some of the venerated institutions of learning and learned societies like the royal Society and British Academy. Its media is still unmatched. The quality newspapers and magazines dominate the civilised world. It is good in sports and also finance.

So, the average level of its human resources, its book publishing  capabilities is very high and above all its English language would give Britain a head start in so many ways.

Its  research and science studies  are still high. But unfortunately, the current world is dominated by  new technologies, IT and biotech and these two industries have much impact on the lives of the planet’s people.

So, Britain must be only too aware about what is good for it and what to look forward to in the world ahead of us.

Image Source : us.macmillan.com

He is clearly the hero and would prove to be a hero for the future too!

BJP acts in a childish manner and behaves in rash ways and that spells doom and disintegration of the major Opposition party.

There is a crisis within the BJP! This crisis, as pointed our by Jaswant Singh himself on the eve of his expulsion, is a fight for power by the party that was once a model for sacrifice.

Now, it is power and power grabbing. It is a pity that L.K.Advani, the senior most leaders himself is caught in this game, it seems. Others don’t seem to care.

A great democracy like India needs a strong and well-knit and ideologically clear Opposition party There is also a lesson for the main political party, namely, the Congress which is no less driven now for the power hungry men and women around it. The Congress response to Jaswant Singh’s expulsion is not happy nor does the Congress party seem to be more mature.

India’s Partition was the greatest tragedy of the freedom struggle era. How can any party, be it BJP or the Congress prevent party leaders or intellectuals or ordinary workers prevent writing or expressing their opinions on the great tragedy?

Jinnah might or might be a demon, let him be an icon for some or demon for others. So too Gandhi, Nehru and Patel too. Every generation, every person with a thinking mind will write and express opinions.

It is all about a lack of genuine commitment among the seniors!

L.K.Advani continues to be the Leader of the Opposition. He wanted to resign at the end of the 2009 elections that gave a setback to the party. Then he changed his mind for whatever reasons he knows best. Then, there was this attempt on his part to elevate Mr.Arun Jaitley, Sushma Swaraj to Rajya Sabha and Lok Sabha leadership.

That was a clear indication that he wanted to downgrade other seniors, the real performers, namely Jaswant Singh and Yashwant Sinha, both won the Lok Sabha elections and both had held the top jobs as Finance and Foreign Ministers.
So, how was that move justified?

First, there was an open revolt. Singh and Sinha openly revolted and spoke against the leadership, this time it was not Rajnath Singh but Advani, seen as the conspirator, so to say! There is every indication that there is a power struggle inside the party.

Rajnath Singh sees himself as a future Prime Minister. More than that, L.K.Advani too sees another opportunity at the end of the next term, after five years!
Nothing wrong to see oneself as the probable future Prime Minister or whatever job you fancy!

But the point is that there must be a genuine introspection. Then came the revolt of Vasundara Raje Scindia, the Rajasthan leader. She refused to resign and put Mr.Rajnath Singh and even the Parliamentary Board in great embarrassment.
This is the first time that we see a new type of party development in India. Clearly this must have sent a jitter to the Congress party which is known for its superficial High Command issuing diktats and appointing all sorts of sundry persons, the same person twice even as the PCC chiefs.

So, Raje’s revolt this time only brought out, in our opinion, the evolving dynamics of the Indian party system. No elections worth the name, no internal democracy whatever, and all parties have now become fiefdoms of one person or family or the sycophants around the person or the family.

So, in this sense, the current crisis in the BJP is welcome for that would only help the Indian political system to learn and live with some internal discussions and debates and even accommodating some healthy dissent. Now, the BJP has come back from Shimla after its baithak chintan and what new ideas for the BJP?

Surely, the party must show a good example, a very ideologically coherent party with a set of ideals and belief systems. The induction of young blood spoken by the RSS chief Mohan Bhagwath is really must be about conducting the affairs of the BJP in a democratic way, its internal democracy must the route through which either the old faces continue or the new faces come in.

It is also time the parties must adhere to conduct their party elections and the Election Commission must do its work much better. It is also time and the UPA has one more priority. That is to bring about some credible electoral reforms. These electoral reforms must help surely to eliminate completely the role of money in the elections.

Even now, in the just held byelections, blatant money power was seen vitiating the atmosphere as in TN. There seems to be no remedy now to take any instant action by the EC once they detect the play of money, the plying of vehicles from outside the constituency etc. So, we welcome the JBP crisis as a sign of the changing times.

The one more recent development of the book on Jinnah by Jaswant Singh and the consequent expulsion of Mr.Singh from the party. This is a very foolish and rash action.

No party can hope to become a mature organisation if it kills any new ideas.
Every competent person must have his own right and freedoms to express his opinions and not every party man can hope to attain the stature of Mr.Jaswant Singh, a rare case of a political leader turning to be a thinker and ideas man!
So let us all feel proud about what Mr.Singh has done for bringing a new debate on Jinnah.

After all we, Indians must treat Pakistan as a friendly country, a brother country and a valued neighbour and we have to become more close and more understanding with the people of Pakistan. Pakistan is a good neighbour and we must all work for it. The Pakistan bashing is an old mindset and also bashing Jinnah is another sign of the old mindset.

Let India play its role to bring Pakistan into our friendly fold. There are progressive forces, seems they are like that, and what Mr.Zardari has done on the Independence Day by introducing reforms in the tribal districts is a welcome step.
So, there are bigger issues that must engage the minds of the party like that of the BJP, no less those of the Congress and other parties.

Let the crisis within the BJP contribute to more liberal reforms in the Indian parties, more internal democracy and more genuine leaders  based on more clearly focused and well-thought out ideological formulations. Thereby Indian democracy would only become more genuine and more well-founded and a force to reckon with in the Indian subcontinent.

What is the real justification?
Even the public-party interaction is more and more shrunk and more and more outsiders are inducted into the party and the government.

Please let there be more democracy inside the party and the government. So too the PCCS and the DCCS.

They must all engage with the general public and must inspire the people.

Image Source : haqeeqat.org